Astros could be huge MLB trade deadline winners if they trade 2 specific players

The Houston Astros have long been known for making bold decisions, and they may be facing another one as the MLB trade deadline approaches. According to insider Buster Olney, rival executives believe the Astros could completely reshape their future if they were willing to trade Jeremy Peña and Isaac Paredes.

While moving two cornerstone infielders would certainly grab headlines, the potential return could position Houston for long-term success while keeping the club competitive.

MORE: One player every MLB team will trade at the 2026 trade deadline

Jeremy Peña Could Command an Enormous Return

Jun 17, 2025; West Sacramento, California, USA; Houston Astros shortstop Jeremy Peña (3) during the game against the Athletics at Sutter Health Park. Mandatory Credit: Sergio Estrada-Imagn Images

Since taking over at shortstop, Jeremy Peña has developed into one of the league’s premier two-way players.

His combination of elite defense, offensive production, and postseason pedigree makes him one of the most valuable trade chips in baseball. It’s rare for a shortstop entering his prime to become available, which is exactly why rival executives believe Houston could receive an overwhelming package in return.

Any team acquiring Peña wouldn’t simply be landing a rental—they’d be adding a foundational player capable of anchoring an infield for years.

Isaac Paredes Is Another Coveted Asset

May 19, 2026; Minneapolis, Minnesota, USA; Houston Astros third baseman Isaac Paredes (15) celebrates hitting a two run home run against the Minnesota Twins in the first inning at Target Field. Mandatory Credit: Jesse Johnson-Imagn Images

Paredes may not receive as much national attention as Peña, but his value around the league remains extremely high.

His ability to play both first and third base, combined with his power at the plate, gives contenders a versatile middle-of-the-order bat who can strengthen multiple areas of a roster.

For clubs looking to upgrade their lineup without sacrificing defensive flexibility, Paredes could become one of the most sought-after hitters available.

MORE: 5 MLB pitchers who will be traded before the trade deadline

Why Houston Might Consider It

If the Astros believe they can replenish their farm system while adding controllable major league talent, it’s a conversation worth having. A pair of blockbuster deals involving Peña and Paredes could bring back multiple top prospects, young starting pitchers, and long-term building blocks that help extend Houston’s championship window.

Rather than watching valuable assets lose value over time, the Astros could capitalize while demand is at its highest.

Of course, moving Peña and Paredes would come with significant risks. Houston remains a competitive organization with postseason aspirations, and subtracting two everyday contributors could hurt its chances of making another deep playoff run. Still, rival executives clearly believe the potential return would outweigh the immediate cost.

If the Astros decide to make either player available, the bidding could become one of the biggest stories of the trade deadline. If they choose to move both, Houston could walk away with one of the largest prospect hauls in recent MLB history.

Whether the front office is willing to take that leap remains to be seen, but one thing is certain: if Jeremy Peña and Isaac Paredes hit the trade market, nearly every contender in baseball will be making a phone call.

— Enjoy free coverage of the top news & trending stories on The Big Lead —