SerpApi.Org
The Reverend Edward Norman, who has died aged 87, was a distinguished church historian who specialised in the 19th and 20th centuries but whose work never received the fullest recognition; this was due partly to his inability to conceal sufficiently his personal, conservative, politics, and partly to his appetite for acrimonious conflict with colleagues.
An Anglican priest in the “High and Dry” tradition, “with the long face and high cheekbones of a Tudor churchman”, Norman first came to wider public attention with his 1978 BBC Reith Lectures on Christianity and the World Order. Well-informed, polemical and elegant of language, these represented the first religious contribution to a growing opposition to the left-of-centre consensus that had dominated British political life since 1945.
He argued that the churches of the West had politicised Christ and thus substituted the moral outlook and political ideas of liberalism for the verities of the historic Christian faith. He cited the Archbishop of Canterbury, Donald Coggan, who had asked: “Do we want to indoctrinate children into our own beliefs?” And answered his own question with: “God forbid.”
Norman’s riposte was that “no one who really believes in his values leaves their acceptance to chance, particularly when it comes to children. Marxists do not; nor should Christians – whose business is indoctrination, if it is anything.”
It was brilliant broadcasting, and amid the ensuring furore Margaret Thatcher identified Norman as her “favourite clergyman”. She was particularly taken, at a meeting of the Conservative Philosophy Group, with his moral defence of nuclear weapons as a means of resisting Soviet materialism, and declared: “I agree with Dr Norman: we must defend Christian values with the ATOM BOMB.”
Several long conversations followed and in due course visits to Chequers, as Mrs Thatcher – “looking for an intellectual to give a pedigree to [her father’s Gladstonian] liberal values”, as Norman put it – tried to hammer out a Christian justification for capitalism. But they had little in common, and he eventually dismissed the prime minister as “not a very deep thinker”.
Norman was Dean of Peterhouse, Cambridge’s oldest and smallest college, from 1971 to 1988, at a time when it was notorious for the ultra-conservatism of its senior Fellows, led by an eminence grise, the historian Maurice Cowling. Norman was very much at home there until the arrival as Master of Lord Dacre – Hugh Trevor-Roper – who, on vacating the Regius chair of Modern History at Oxford, had reluctantly agreed to preside over what seemed, even to him, to be a society frozen in the past.
The ensuing High Table spats, normally hidden from view in more harmonious surroundings, were relayed far and wide and caused considerable amusement in academic circles. From this unedifying spectacle, Norman, in particular, emerged poorly.
When the Regius chair of Ecclesiastical History at Oxford became vacant in 1984, a great fear fell upon the faculty of Divinity lest the appointment go to Norman, who was clearly well qualified for the professorship but unlikely to be easy company. To the relief of many, the chair was suppressed for several years for want of funds. At York Minster, where he was a Canon from 1995 to 2004, the scope for conflict was slightly reduced but he still managed to ruffle some feathers.
For a decade, from 1993, Norman contributed a “Meditation” column to Saturday’s Daily Telegraph. These were minor masterpieces of condensed and thoughtful Christianity, widely read and great appreciated by older readers who had been made either anxious or angry by their church’s departure from traditional worship and teaching. The publication of two collections, Out of the Depths (2001) and The Mercy of God’s Humility (2004), provided the author with an opportunity in their prefaces to castigate the bishops responsible for this “betrayal”. The only changes of which he really approved were those relating to homosexuality.
His retirement from York Minister’s chapter in 2004 was heralded by the publication of Anglican Difficulties: A New Syllabus of Errors, which indicated that his long love-hatred with the Church of England had finally lost the element of love. Telling The Daily Telegraph that the Church of England had lost its authority to such an extent that it was no longer “a church; it’s more of a religious society,” he announced that he was to be received into the Church of Rome.
Edward Robert Michael Norman was born at Chatham on November 22 1938. His parents having moved to Walthamstow, he attended the local Sir George Monoux Grammar School, then taught for a short time at the neighbouring secondary modern before going up to Selwyn College, Cambridge, to read history as a scholar.
A First led to a Fellowship at the college and in 1964 he moved to a similar post at Jesus College, combining this with a university lectureship in history. He also held a Nato research fellowship for two years.
His first book, The Catholic Church in Ireland (1965), was based on a PhD thesis. It was followed by The Conscience of the State in North America (1967), the fruits of his NATO research, and Victorian Anti-Catholicism (1967).
His most important book was Church and Society in England: 1770-1970 (1976), which wrongfooted reviewers by being both a magisterial survey of the Church of England’s thinking on social issues, unlikely to be superseded, and a conservative polemic, advancing the thesis that Anglican radicalism was never a democratic or popular current of thought, but always the preserve of an “armchair socialist” elite. The final chapter laid into the woolly liberals of the 1970s Anglican church, who were prepared to defend the ethics of terrorist bomb-making and free love.
Norman’s hero in Anglican history was Hensley Henson (1863-1947), Bishop of Durham, acerbic, combative, Tory and lower-middle-class. He would quote with approval (and thinking of himself) the opening words of Henson’s memoirs: “I belong to the middle-class, and to the soundest part of it... that which from time immemorial has lived and worked in the country.”
A short preparation for Holy Orders at Lincoln Theological College took him into the diaconate in 1965, but he did not proceed to the priesthood until required to do so by his appointment as Dean of Peterhouse six years later.
Earlier he had flirted with Marxism and during the 1960s was among those clad in jeans and a leather jackets – the latter suggesting the influence of Elvis Presley, of whose rock and roll music he was a lifelong devotee. Much later, at York Minister, he marked the 25th anniversary of the great star’s death by mentioning his name at Evensong, and wearing an improvised leather stole.
Appointment as Dean of Peterhouse in 1971, however, coincided with a personal swing to the Right. The college was famed for its isolation from the rest of the university, for the quality of its victuals and fine cellar, and for the frequent rudeness to guests at High Table. This combination inspired Tom Sharpe’s novel Porterhouse Blue (1974) and a subsequent popular television series.
As a newcomer, Norman was not initially a member of the ruling cabal, but before long he was contributing to its well-lubricated machinations. This became more significant in 1980 when a new Master was required. The hunt was for someone who would not challenge the status quo, and in particular not seek to admit women undergraduates – or, as Norman put it, “let the scrubbers in”.
A division of opinion about two other possible candidates led to the election of Hugh Trevor-Roper (by now Lord Dacre), who, it was confidently believed, would more than adequately fit the bill. But they had misjudged a man who could not by any stretch of the imagination be described as a progressive, yet nonetheless recognised the need for some change – including the admission of women.
This was not the only point of conflict within the college, nor was Norman the only combatant, but a moment arrived when the Dean informed one of his colleagues that he had “declared war” on the Master. The Master expressed to a friend the opinion that “the Dean is mad.” Much unpleasantness followed.
Trevor-Roper was never invited by the Dean to preach in the chapel of his own college. In the end, Norman refused to greet or speak to him, except in altercation, and went out of his way to snub him at what was supposed to be a convivial occasion on the eve of his retirement. This was followed by a review in the Times Literary Supplement which began: “There has been no distinguished Master of Peterhouse since the retirement of Professor Herbert Butterfield in 1968.”
Trevor-Roper was content to sum up his own achievement at the college by declaring: “I have brought the Fellows of Peterhouse to order, but not to life.”
Yet there other sides to Norman’s complex personality. He was an excellent teacher and sensitive pastor to the undergraduates (among them, Michael Portillo). For seven years he served as a much-valued chaplain to Addenbrooke’s Hospital, and later, at York, when the head verger jumped to his death from one of the towers of the Minster, he was immediately on the scene to support the shocked verger team.
Retirement from the Peterhouse battlefield took him in 1988 to the more tranquil pastures of Christ’s College, Canterbury – a training college for teachers – as Dean of Chapel. The Archbishop of Canterbury made him a Six Preacher of the cathedral, a venerable office he much valued.
If these were hardly the prestigious appointments that had once beckoned, it was now clear that the avenues to academic promotion were closed to him. The Archbishop of York, David Hope, came to the rescue in 1995 with the offer of a canonry of York Minster.
Late-20th-century cathedral life was hardly his forte and he doubted the seriousness of their congregations, believing them to be seeking only emotional and aesthetic satisfaction. Moreover, he disliked the intricacies of ceremonial, while his devotion to the Book of Common Prayer led inevitably to discomfort with the variety of modern alternative rites.
Norman was nonetheless an outstandingly fine preacher. Three or four headings on a single sheet of paper were sufficient prompts to bring forth from him sermons of considerable erudition and spiritual depth. Appointment as Chancellor in 1999 also made him responsible for the Minster’s education programme, and his lectures were valued for their unusual subjects and polemical vigour. This combination received wider notice with a book, An Anglican Catechism (2001), which won the approval of the Archbishop of York and included the declaration that homosexuality was “divinely ordered and with positive qualities”.
Once again, however, Norman was the focus of division within his colleagues. The activities of the recently appointed Dean, Raymond Furnell, who had been charged with solving the Minister’s acute financial problems, proved particularly vexatious to him.
The new Dean’s style was brusquely efficient and sparks soon began to fly, fanning to a conflagration when Furnell proposed the introduction of admission charges and the closure of the historic library. The Archbishop intervened to save the library, but not the pockets of the visitors. Norman’s parting shot, when announcing his retirement, was that York Minster was “a second-rate Gothic building, erected on the cheap”.
Norman had in many ways been a lonely member of the Minster community. He was usually to be found alone at lunchtime (occasionally with the Archbishop) at table in an Italian restaurant. It was his only meal of the day, accompanied by a bottle of good wine. A stock of sandwiches, purchased early in the week, sustained him between times.
Despite dramatically announcing his conversion to Roman Catholicism in The Daily Telegraph in 2004, it seemed that his devotion to the Book of Common Prayer was too close to permit detachment from it. He became an honorary curate of the churches of St Andrew-in-the-Wardrobe and St James, Garlickhythe, in the City of London – these being the headquarters of the Prayer Book Society. He commuted from a flat in Brighton.
It was not until Pope Benedict XVI announced in 2009 the formation of an Ordinariate in which Anglican converts might retain their former liturgies that he felt able to move. This he did at the Shrine of Our Lady of Walsingham in 2012. With typical unpredictability, however, he then confided in friends that the Ordinariate was too “Anglo-Catholic” for his tastes and that he preferred to attend Mass in an ordinary Roman Catholic parish.
He was unmarried.
The Rev Edward Norman, born November 22 1938, died April 13 2026
