SerpApi.Org
More than half of the global workforce now reports experiencing financial strain. Yet when employers struggle with attendance, staffing shortages, or declining reliability, the explanation almost always points in the same direction: younger generations simply don’t want to work.
After nearly two decades running a staffing firm that places hourly, in-person professionals, I believe we’ve been misdiagnosing the problem. America’s work ethic hasn’t disappeared. Inflation has weakened the incentive structure that once made showing up feel like a path to something bigger.
I have a front-row seat to one of the most overlooked shifts in today’s labor market. The jobs I recruit for, from substitute teachers to paraprofessionals, cannot be performed remotely, which means reliability isn’t simply preferred; it is fundamental to the job itself.
Just a few years ago, an employee failing to show up was an exception. Today, it has become a recurring challenge. One substitute teacher assigned to proctor a 7 a.m. state exam arrived at 9 a.m. and asked, “Isn’t it better that I came at 9 than not at all?”
It would be easy to dismiss that exchange as one employee’s poor judgment. I don’t. I see it as a symptom of a labor market where the connection between effort and reward has weakened. When homeownership, financial security, and upward mobility feel increasingly out of reach, accountability becomes harder to sustain, not because standards have changed, but because the incentives behind them have.
For generations, people accepted early mornings, difficult commutes, and demanding jobs because they believed those sacrifices created a better future. A paycheck meant more than paying this month’s bills. It represented progress toward buying a home, owning a reliable car, or building long-term financial security.
Today, that promise feels increasingly distant for many hourly workers.
Financial pressures remain one of the biggest concerns shaping employees’ outlook on work. At the same time, housing affordability continues to dominate economic discussions across the country, leaving many workers questioning whether working harder will actually change their financial future.
That distinction matters because work ethic has never existed in isolation. It has always been shaped by incentives. When people believe their effort creates meaningful progress, commitment follows. When that belief begins to erode, motivation often does too.
This is not a defense of poor attendance or unreliable employees. Employers have every right to expect accountability. But accountability alone does not explain why schools, healthcare providers, retailers, and service businesses across the country are reporting many of the same staffing challenges.
From where I sit, these aren’t isolated incidents. They’re early warning signs of a labor market under growing economic strain. The disconnect becomes even more obvious when I recruit for positions that clearly state they are on-site.
One of the first questions applicants often ask is, “Can this be remote?”
I understand why they ask. Remote and hybrid work fundamentally changed expectations after the pandemic. Many workers now value flexibility as highly as compensation, and for office-based professions, that shift makes perfect sense.
But many essential jobs cannot be performed through a laptop. A teacher cannot supervise a classroom remotely. A caregiver cannot support an elderly client over Zoom. A paraprofessional cannot help a child learn from another city.
The problem is not that people want flexibility. The challenge is that expectations have evolved faster than many essential professions ever could. That mismatch is becoming one of the defining tensions in today’s labor market.
I also think we spend far too much time turning this into a generational debate.
I was raised by two baby boomer parents who believed showing up to work was simply part of being an adult. That mindset shaped how I view responsibility, but it also reminds me that every generation is ultimately shaped by the economic realities it inherits.
But four generations now share today’s workforce. That should be one of our greatest competitive advantages, giving younger professionals the opportunity to learn from experienced colleagues while bringing fresh ideas of their own.
Instead, we have reduced a complicated economic issue to a conversation about age. That misses the bigger picture. People still want purpose. More importantly, they want to believe that hard work will move them forward. Increasingly, many no longer do.
The challenge is that many don’t believe those outcomes are achievable through the jobs available to them. We cannot rebuild trust in work by repeatedly telling people to work harder while ignoring the economic conditions shaping their decisions.
This is not a partisan argument, nor is it an excuse for lowering standards. Businesses still need dependable employees, and workers still have a responsibility to honor their commitments. But if we continue treating a declining work ethic as a disease instead of asking what caused it, we will continue misdiagnosing the problem.
From my point of view inside the hourly labor market, the warning signs are impossible to ignore.
I don’t believe the workforce suddenly lost its work ethic. I believe it is responding to an economy where, for too many people, showing up no longer feels like the first step toward ownership, stability, or upward mobility.
Until the promise of upward mobility begins to feel attainable again, I believe employers will continue fighting the same staffing battles. We can keep blaming a generation for the state of the workforce, or we can confront the economic reality reshaping it. From where I sit, the answer isn’t difficult to see.
Katie Warnock is the CEO of Staffing Boutique, a New York-based staffing firm specializing in education, nonprofit, and mission-driven organizations. With more than two decades of experience recruiting and advising employers across the hourly workforce, she writes about labor market trends, workforce dynamics, and the economic forces shaping employment in the United States. Warnock is a passionate advocate for taking the necessary steps to preserve mental health through physical activity, nutrition, sleep hygiene, and sunlight exposure, all of which help to decrease workforce burnout.
The views expressed in this article are the writer’s own.
Related Articles
