SerpApi.Org
If you have a kid who "just doesn't care," you may be at a loss when all of the conventional homework motivation tips—stickers, promises of a trip to a toy store, threats of punishment—fall short. "What actually motivates children?" you may find yourself asking. It may sound scary to give a kid who seems to be floundering some agency, but there's something to be said for child psychology and autonomy.
"Autonomy refers to feeling a sense of ownership, choice or voice in what they are doing," Dr. Amy Kincaid Todey, Ph.D., a clinical psychologist, tells Parade. "When children feel they have some control over their actions, they are more likely to engage because the activity feels personally meaningful rather than something being imposed upon them."
Does that mean your kid is running the show and making all the decisions at home? Uh—no.
"It means giving them age-appropriate opportunities to participate, contribute and have some say in their lives," Dr. Todey clarifies.
She shares that, in child psychology, connection is as important as autonomy. She notes that kids thrive when parents and grandparents blend warmth and support with age-appropriate expectations for a challenge.
"The goal is not to remove every obstacle from a child's path, nor is it to leave children to struggle on their own," she says. "Rather, effective parents create a secure base from which children can stretch, grow and develop confidence."
That sounds incredible in theory, but how does it play out in real life? Four child psychologists share the best motivation for kids. They also dig into why common motivation strategies, like positive reinforcement for kids (read: bribes), don't usually work.
The #1 Thing That Actually Motivates Kids: Intrinsic Motivation
According to all four child psychologists we spoke with, intrinsic motivationactually motivates kids. Intrinsic motivation is doing something because it's personally rewarding and satisfying, not because you're going to get a reward or external validation for it.
Compared to extrinsic motivation—rewards-based motivation—intrinsic motivation keeps children working toward completing a task even if there isn't a reward, a reminder or a supervisor (like a parent) watching. It builds competence and confidence in kids.
Related: We Asked 4 Child Psychologists What Parenting Style Is Best—They All Said the Same Thing
Intrinsic vs. Extrinsic Motivation: Why Bribes Backfire
For a long time, positive reinforcement for kids—sticker charts, toys for straight As, money for scoring a goal in soccer—was considered the "gold standard" of motivation strategies. It's well-intentioned enough: It focuses on good behavior rather than harsh scolding (or worse). Yet, child psychologists warn that it has pitfalls.
"When rewards become the primary reason for behavior, children may begin focusing on the reward rather than the value of the activity itself," explains Dr. Ioana Pal, Psy.D., a licensed clinical psychologist at Stramski Children’s Development Center at Miller Children’s & Women’s Hospital.
She says that over-reliance on rewards—extrinsic motivation—can:
- Reduce the enjoyment of the activity.
- Create a “What’s in it for me?” mindset.
- Decrease persistence once rewards disappear.
- Shift motivation from internal to external.
"A child who once read because reading was enjoyable may begin reading only when a reward is offered," Dr. Pal adds.
Related: We Asked 3 Child Psychologists What Compliment Is Best for Kids—They All Said the Same Thing
7 Expert Strategies To Build Intrinsic Motivation
OK, so sticker charts and ice cream may not help keep a child motivated in the long term. Intrinsic motivation can build an innate desire to keep moving, even when challenges get in the way. But not every child naturally has this. Child psychologists share tips with Parade for building intrinsic motivation in kids.
1. Learn what's getting in the way
Dr. Todey shares that a "lack of motivation" is often a symptom rather than the real problem.
"Before asking, 'How do I motivate my child?' it is often more helpful to ask, 'What is getting in the way of motivation?'" she suggests.
She says children may appear unmotivated because:
- The task is too difficult.
- The task is too easy or boring.
- They are anxious about failure.
- They lack confidence.
- They don’t understand the task's purpose.
- They are overwhelmed, stressed or emotionally struggling.
- They have attention, learning, executive functioning or mental health challenges.
- They have become reliant on external rewards.
2. Praise the effort, not the outcome
Praising effort vs. intelligence and results is another way to build confidence and intrinsic motivation in kids, child psychologists agree.
"Praising effort is much more productive than praising outcome because we have little control over outcome," explains Dr. Brett A. Biller, Psy.D., the Mental Health Director at Audrey Hepburn Children’s House at Hackensack University Medical Center. "When looking to motivate our children, it is effort that we seek to impact."
He explains that praising the effort enhances feelings around "the work." Kids can fall in love with the process (or at least learn to tolerate it), increasing their intrinsic motivation.
3. Assess the challenge
Parents and grandparents should align challenges with a child's development, which can vary even among kids of the same age.
"Motivation tends to be highest when a task falls within a child’s 'just right' zone—challenging enough to feel meaningful but achievable enough to feel successful," Dr. Pal notes.
She says parents can evaluate whether something is too easy or too hard by asking themselves:
- Does the child complete it effortlessly and seem bored?
- Does the child avoid it, become frustrated, or give up quickly?
- Does the child need moderate support but can ultimately succeed?
"If a task is too easy, increase responsibility or challenge," Dr. Pal recommends. "If it is too difficult, break it into smaller steps, provide support and celebrate progress toward mastery. Scaffolding works and may be necessary for some children."
4. Give them age-appropriate autonomy
Understanding whether something is too easy or hard for a child's developmental stage lets parents offer age-appropriate autonomy.
Dr. Todey shares that this might look like:
- Toddlers and preschoolers: Putting toys away, helping feed a pet, placing napkins on the table, or putting clothes in a hamper.
- School-aged children: Begin making their bed, packing their backpack, helping prepare simple meals, folding laundry or taking responsibility for portions of their homework routine.
- Tweens and teens: Increasing ownership of school assignments, laundry, meal preparation, budgeting small amounts of money and managing portions of their schedule.
"Across all ages, responsibility serves another important function: it helps children feel that they matter," she notes. "Contributing to family life allows children to experience competence, but it also fosters belonging. When children feel that they play a meaningful role within their family and that their contributions have value, they are often more motivated to engage and participate."
5. Help them understand the why
You have a reason for asking your child to complete a task, like homework or the laundry, but do they know it? Explaining your intention to them can help build intrinsic motivation.
"Children are more motivated when they understand the purpose behind what they are doing," Dr. Todey explains. "Many adults are more willing to work hard when they understand how a task connects to their goals or values, and children are no different."
For instance, instead of saying "Clean your room because I said so," she says that a parent might explain: "Taking care of your space helps you find the things you need and creates a calmer environment."
"Helping children connect tasks to a larger purpose creates meaning, and meaning is one of the strongest drivers of intrinsic motivation," the psychologist notes.
6. Connect the task to their interests
Dr. Holly Schiff, Psy.D., a licensed clinical psychologist who treats children, notes that kids are more motivated if the activity feels relevant.
"A parent might connect reading to a child's favorite sports team, science project, video game or hobby," she says. "When tasks align with existing interests, children are more likely to experience enjoyment, curiosity and a sense of ownership, which strengthens intrinsic motivation."
7. Allow for natural consequences
What are natural consequences, anyway?
"Natural consequences are outcomes that occur without a parent artificially creating a punishment," Dr. Schiff explains. "For example, forgetting a jacket may lead to feeling cold, or failing to charge a device may mean it's unavailable later."
It makes sense. There isn't exactly a direct line between "no dessert" (a punishment) and "not charging your phone" (natural consequences of your actions—or lack thereof).
"Natural consequences can be powerful teachers because they help children make direct connections between choices and outcomes, which often feels more meaningful than lectures or punishments," she adds.
Related: 7 ‘Helpful’ Phrases That Actually Cause Anxiety in Kids, Child Psychologist Warns
How To Motivate a Kid Who 'Doesn’t Care': 3 Tips from Child Psychologists
It can be so frustrating when all of the motivation strategies above "don't work." Child psychologists stress it's important to stay the course. They offer a few more tips for motivating a child who doesn't care.
1. Lead with empathy
Dr. Todey shares that one of the most powerful responses is to acknowledge that something is hard.
"Statements such as, 'That sounds really difficult,' or 'I can see why you're frustrated,' help children feel understood rather than judged," she says. "Empathy communicates that their emotional experience matters and often reduces the sense of isolation that can accompany struggle."
2. Stay with them
The struggle is real—for you and the child. But Dr. Todey urges parents to avoid "snowplowing."
"Parents often feel pressure to make difficult feelings disappear, but children do not always need solutions," she explains. "Sometimes they need company. Sitting quietly with a child, listening, offering a hug if welcomed or simply remaining present communicates an important message: You do not have to go through this alone."
3. Make them a part of decisions
Dr. Biller describes empowering kids to feel like they're a part of decisions as "one of the most impactful ways to improve a child's motivation."
"That is not to say that children should be provided the choice of what they want to do," he says. "Rather, a child will be more motivated when they perceive they have influence on the action that they are being asked to engage in."
For instance, he says that many children will be more motivated to get dressed if you ask them if they'd prefer wearing one color shirt or another, rather than simply saying, "Get dressed."
Easier mornings, here we come.
Up Next:
Related: We Asked 3 Child Psychologists What Hobby Is Best for Kids—They All Said the Same Thing
Sources:
- Dr. Amy Kincaid Todey, Ph.D., is a clinical psychologist.
- Dr. Brett A. Biller, Psy.D., is the Mental Health Director at Audrey Hepburn Children’s House at Hackensack University Medical Center.
- Dr. Holly Schiff, Psy.D., is a licensed clinical psychologist who treats children.
- Dr. Ioana Pal, Psy.D., is a licensed clinical psychologist at Stramski Children’s Development Center at Miller Children’s & Women’s Hospital.
