It’s the only “candy” I buy—they’re that good.
If you’re already a Trader Joe’s loyalist, you probably already know about these, but if not, let me introduce you to TJ’s Dark Chocolate Peanut Butter Cups. Here’s the deal: I grew up in a health-conscientious household—I’m talking fig newtons for dessert and virtually no processed foods—so I’ve never had a big hankering for candy or store-bought sweets…except when it comes to good chocolate. And these bite-sized peanut butter cups pass the test.
The store has many cult-favorite items from Unexpected Cheddar Cheese and Jalapeño Limeade to the well-priced wine section’s Espiral Vino Verde—all of which are my go-to’s as well. And while the frozen prepared foods and snack sections are also full of gems, my favorite item typically sits on a shelf above the freezers among a variety of other chocolate-covered treats. At just $5.99 for a 16‑ounce tub, these Dark Chocolate Peanut Butter Cups are the splurge I never skip. Here’s why they’re irresistible.
Why I Love These Dark Chocolate Peanut Butter Cups
- They’re a bang for your buck
- A bite-sized indulgence that always curbs a sweet craving with a hint of salty
- They’ll last a while in your pantry or freezer—that is unless you eat them first! (Warning: they’re rather addicting.)
- Made with few ingredients
What Makes Them So Good
While I’ve raved about these before, the product also gets high marks from many avid Trader Joe’s shoppers and foodies alike. Another food editor agreed with my love for them saying, “Just thinking about getting them makes my day a little brighter,” and I second that! These peanut butter cups impress my critical palette as they’re not too sweet or fake tasting.
For me, this slightly bitter-sweet dark chocolate treat with a true salty peanut butter filling is like a leveled-up Reese’s. The chocolate shell is a perfectly balanced soft and hard exterior that cracks just right when you take a bite. Inside, the filling is a smooth, but not too creamy or crumbly mixture that actually tastes like peanut butter. And even if you’re not a dark chocolate fan, they have a milk chocolate option—though I take a strong stance that the dark chocolate ones are far superior.
Though I may still indulge in a Reese’s cup on occasion (especially the holiday-shaped ones because everyone knows they’re better!), and I’ve tried other brands like Skinny Dipped and Justin’s chocolate peanut butter cups, none hold a candle to this Trader Joe’s version with the just-right level of sweetness. Plus, they also have minimal added ingredients compared to other brands.
Not to mention, the price per cup is unbeatable—$5.99 for a 16‑ounce tub which contains approximately 36 cups. But if you don’t want the tub, they also sell small packs of individually wrapped ones by the checkout. (But I promise, you’ll want the tub.) I can’t explain it, but I swear the unwrapped ones just taste better too.
You’re welcome for your new favorite sweet treat that’s the perfect pick-me-up or end of the night bite.
Read the original article on Southern Living